Philip Seymour Hoffman · 2002

2 Philip Seymour Hoffman movies from 2002 on 4K Blu-ray, ranked S to D by transfer quality. 1 S-Tier pick including Punch-Drunk Love.

Decade

All 16 1990s 7 2000s 5 2010s 4

Year

All 5 2000 0 2001 0 2002 2 2003 1 2004 0 2005 0 2006 1 2007 0 2008 1 2009 0

Punch-Drunk Love(2002)

7.1/10

dir. Paul Thomas Anderson

S-Tier

S-Tier Criterion 4K with a 4.5 score. PTA's romantic comedy with Adam Sandler, and the Criterion 4K and the Sony 4K from the Columbia Classics box have slightly different aspect ratios from different masters. People want more PTA on 4K, especially Boogie Nights, Magnolia, and There Will Be Blood. A Boogie Nights steelbook was announced separately, which suggests PTA's catalog won't all land at Criterion.

Criterion Collection · 4K + Blu-ray

Red Dragon(2002)

7.0/10

dir. Brett Ratner

C-Tier

Most of the discussion around Red Dragon circles back to Manhunter instead. Collectors keep asking when Mann's version will get a proper 4K, and Red Dragon threads reliably turn into Manhunter appreciation posts. The Kino disc is competent but the C-Tier rating reflects Brett Ratner's direction more than the transfer itself.

Kino Lorber · 4K + Blu-ray